Showing posts with label Peter Singer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Peter Singer. Show all posts

Sunday, 25 February 2018

Peter Singer and Siobhan O'Sullivan discuss 'Animal Liberation'

This is a transcript of an episode of the Knowing Animals podcast which was released on 13/8/17. You can listen to the audio version here: 

My very sincere thanks to Arnav who transcribed this episode!

Happy reading!



Episode 9: Liberating Animals with Peter Singer

13/08/2017

SO: Hey guys! Welcome to Knowing Animals, a podcast where we talk to an animal studies scholar about a piece of their work. I’m Siobhan O’Sullivan and I do like knowing animals.

Today we’ll be discussing Peter Singer’s work “Animal Liberation” which was first published by Harper Collins in 1975. It’s now in it’s fourth edition. Welcome to the podcast Peter Singer!

PS: Thank you Siobhan, great to be with you. Just a tiny correction, Harper Collins only came into this quite late. The paperback edition was originally published by the New York review of books in New York and then later on got into paperback first with Avon, and now with Harper Collins.

SO: Ah well, I’ll have to write to the people at Wikipedia. PS: Oh yes, you’d better go online and correct it – edit it.

SO: Exactly. Well thank you so much for joining us Peter, it’s a great honour to have you here and as we’re going to see at the end of the podcast I always ask my guests five quick questions one of which is what was the first piece of work you read and you’re the most cited author so to have the source here is absolutely wonderful.
So let me start by asking you what inspired you to write the book “Animal Liberation?”

PS: I wanted to write animal liberation because I became aware of the way animals
are treated and I just thought that there’s something going on here that most people don’t know about. People like me, I was already in my 20’s, I was a graduate student at Oxford university, I considered my self reasonably well informed on what you might call broadly issues of social justice – I was active opposing the Vietnam War, of course

page1image3734288
I opposed racial discrimination and so on. Women’s rights movement, but nobody talked about animals and what we were doing to animals and I thought this is something going on beneath the surface that needs to be exposed and not just exposed in terms of here’s a catalogue of horrible cruelties that we do but actually put in a systematic framework that shows that this is an important issue alongside all of those other issues that I just mentioned.

SO: Do you think it still is one of the lesser known issues or do you think that has changed?

PS: Oh I think that has changed dramatically. Its very often in the media and attitudes have changed to a small extent, practices have changed, but not nearly enough but people are aware, you know, you say animal rights to someone now and they don’t look at you as if to say “What’s that animals don’t have rights,” whereas nobody put animals and rights together in the 1970’s, early 70’s.

SO: Well certainly your book was a large part of that concept becoming known, so the idea of animal rights. Thinking about animals rights and your book “Animal Liberation,” is there something you’re most proud of or something that you’re most proud of?

PS: Look I’m really pleased that I wrote it and I’m really pleased it’s influenced a lot of people. Every time somebody comes up to me after a talk and says “I read Animal Liberation” x years ago and I’ve been vegetarian or vegan since. Yeah, I’m proud that and I’m proud that I’ve written a book that’s been able to change something as fundamental as what people eat and the attitudes that go along with that.

SO: So, its an iconic book and of course it’s often cited, it’s used by scholars but its also used by as you noted very accessible and people in the community are reading it – are there any particular principles or themes that people misunderstood or misrepresent when they talk about your work?

PS: The most misinterpretation of the work is the idea that animals and humans being equal, and to some extent I suppose I am responsible for that because the first chapter is called all animals are equal, and in that chapter I try and describe in what sense I mean that because of course there’s all sorts of things you can make when you say
two things are equal. And I’m pretty clear that I don’t mean to say for instance that it’s just as bad to kill a non human animal as it is to kill a normal human being, and I say what I do mean is that the pain or suffering of an animal ought to count just as much as the similar pain or suffering of a human being, that we shouldn’t say because one of them is homosapien, it’s pain matters more and if the other one is, whatever it might be that it’s pain doesn’t count or doesn’t count as much.
So many people, particularly opponents that haven’t really read the book I think just assume that I’m saying its just as bad to kill a rat than it would be to kill any human being and I’m pretty clear that that’s no what I’m saying.

SO: Right, well that brings me to the next question I had – so, correct me if im wrong, I’m sure you will, we’ve had conversations in the past where you’ve suggested this issue of death and what death might mean for non human animals is maybe something that is perhaps worthy of revision or other people presented arguments that you thought were compelling. Is there something in the book animal liberation that you think you didn’t get right or that you wish you had presented in a different way or framed in a different way?

PS: Ahh, so the issue about when or why killing animals is wrong is an issue I’ve struggled with. I did change slightly what I wrote in the first edition when I came to do the second edition and particularly when people use the argument that if animals have good lives, and of course this is a tiny minority of the animals that are produced for food, but if animals are produced for food and given good lives, and if that can only happen if the farmer is permitted to kill the animals to sell them for meat, then is it really wrong to kill them given that otherwise they wouldn’t have existed at all and given the assumption that their lives are good. So that’s always struck me as one of the more difficult philosophical questions in this area. And it still strikes me that way, and I wouldn’t say that that I’m satisfied with any particular answer on that and it’s good to see that there is ongoing philosophical discussion, there the book Tatjana Visak wrote called Killing Happy Animals and Tatjana and Robert Garner have edited a book with essays on that topic, so I think I welcome the fact that there is ongoing discussion to deal with that problem.

SO: Hmm, so that’s really the issue that you see as perhaps in need of further thought? The issue of where to draw the line, is that something that’s occupied your mind in the years since you wrote Animal Liberation or...?

PS: There are certainly issues about what kinds of beings are sentient or conscious, I mean that’s the sort of, that’s in a way a factual question, I mean it’s obviously got philosophical overtones in terms of what we regard as consciousness and what’s evidence of consciousness, but I mean in one sense I know where to draw the line – you draw the line where there’s sentience, where there’s a consciousness, where there’s a capacity to feel pain or pleasure. So philosophically I have a clear answer to that but if somebody then says “Well, what about insects?” you know can an ant feel pain, it’s very hard I think to know the answer to that question so yes I still... it’s not a question I struggle with philosophically as much I do with questions about killing but it’s still a question I’m still really interested in seeing what kind of evidence can be produced and can our knowledge advance to the extent that we could have good grounds to answering questions about various kinds of animals who are quite unlike us in many respects.

SO: Hmm, well I was at a conference a while ago, a political philosophy conference and there was this special panel on animals and a particular topic was being discussed and I said “Ah well no, for me there’s no sentience implication so the action is fine,” and they all said “Oh you’re such a Singerite, blah blah blah blah blah,” then this was not meant as a compliment I think. Are you still confident sentience is the issue?

PS: Yeah, absolutely and I’m not sure what people think might be the issue or why they would think that if it’s not going to be sentience. I mean once you abandon sentience why are we concerned with animals rather than plants? Seems to me that the fact that perhaps not all but many animals are sentient and in my view there’s no evidence that any plants are sentient, no good evidence, is a reason for why we talk about animals liberation and not the liberation of all living beings, all living things.

SO: And so the issue of the kind of framework that you use versus kind of rights discourse which is so powerful, have you ever been swayed or have you ever thought that maybe a rights framework could useful or you’re very committed to your framework and the rights discourse.

PS: Look I think a rights framework is useful in terms of political discussions and I’ve never denied that as for humans it is to say that somebody has a right to something is a clear shorthand way of saying that we should not be doing something to someone or we should do something that will help them achieve their rights and the same is true for animals – if someone wants to say that animals have rights not to be experimented

on, not to have cosmetics in they’re eyes or not to be packed up in factory farms, that’s clear and understandable, and I don’t have any objection to that. If you then say well what’s the basis for this claim, I think the basis for the claim can’t just be “They have rights” in other words can’t just be repeating this is if it’s a sort of obvious observable fact because it isn’t. it has to be something like they have interests or they’re interests are being harmed in this way, recognising either n terms of social practice or in terms of the law that it’s a violation of they’re rights to treat them this is likely to stop that treatment so let’s recognise that they have rights. I don’t have any philosophical problems with putting it that way.

SO: So you will have been exposed to many counter arguments – now I’m not talking about from within animal protection scholarship but from people who are opposed to that kind of scholarship or who believe its ill founded, it’s incorrect. I’ve heard you say previously that you’ve heard very little that you think is a compelling argument against what you put forward in animal liberation – is that still the case?

PS: Yeah, I think I’ve heard very little that is fundamentally against the idea of speciesism as I understand it – as we were saying earlier that there had been some criticisms that missed the mark because they’re not attacking what I’m saying and there have certainly been some criticisms on these what I would say issues around the edge of what I’m saying which are issues about killing and issues about how we should think about insects or about other invertebrates. Now those are important issues but I haven’t really seen a good argument for saying the fact that a being is not a member of our species is a reason for giving less consideration to its interests.

SO: So do you know why in that case, and I agree, I find your argument very compelling and I’m yet to hear anything that has swayed me in that view. Why do we not have 100% take up with such an argument?

PS: Well obviously that argument challenges the way we act with regard to animals and it challenges practices that most people are complicit in. If they’re not vegan, they are complicit in practices that harm the interests of animals, let me say if they’re not vegan and they’re not extremely selective about finding you know farms that really treat animals well and only eating those animal products then its clear that they are complicit in speciesism, and so they have an interest in resisting that argument and unfortunately that kind of consideration partly habit partly how they perceive they’re self interest, I don’t think it’s really in their self interest to continue to eat meat but how they see it,

but I think that’s a powerful obstacle, its very difficult to convince people when they see what they regard as central interests or central parts of their way of living as being threatened by the argument.

SO: Hmm, so self interest trumping logic.

PS: Yeah unfortunately it does that in lots of areas, not only this one.


SO: Okay well thank you very much Peter. Now I ask all my guests to answer 5 quick questions at the end of the podcast, now I’d be particularly interested in what you have to say. So first up, can you recall the first piece of pro animal scholarship you ever read?

PS: Umm, it would’ve been work for the book “Animals: Men and Morals” that was edited by Stanley and Gozlam Godovich and John Harris. Perhaps it was Rod Golovich’s paper because I’d met her in Oxford and she was certainly one of the people who opened my eyes to what was happening to animals.

PO: So can you recall the first piece of animal scholarship that you ever wrote?

PS: Yes, the first thing that I wrote was a review of that book that I just mentioned by Animals: Men and Morals which I reviewed for the New York review for books in April 1973, and I should say it was my suggestion to the editor of the New York review Robert Silvers that they should cover the book because otherwise there’s no way in the world they would have because as I said animal issues were off the radar and that book was published in England basically sank without a trace it wasn’t reviewed in any of the major papers or magazines or anything like that which is why I was so keen that it should be reviewed in the us when the us version came out.

SO: and so that’s amazing you hadn’t written any papers throughout your time as a student – the first thing was this iconic review that then...

PS: That’s right, because the first I ever thought about this issue was coming into contact with some of the people involved in Animals: Men and Morals who were in Oxford and then I thought this is fine, they’re writing these essays, they’re editing this book of essays so there’s nothing for me to say here because they’re already doing this. Now as I said when the book came out in England nobody seemed to notice it – it wasn’t discussed at all and that’s when I thought this book really deserves more attention and my views were not identical with those of the Gulovich’s or the contributors to that book but they at least broadly in the same ballpark so I tried to put the arguments of a number of different contributors (because it’s a collection of essays) into an overarching framework and I used the heading Animal Liberation for that. And that was the first thing that I did.

SO: And do you know why this particular issue spoke to you? When you said earlier that you were passionate about quite a range of social justice issues but animal issues has obviously also been particularly important to you, do you know why this spoke to you?

PS: You know I think I had been brought up with some sensitivity to animal suffering, my father certainly had sensitivity to animal suffering, not that he would talk about it a great deal. I can remember for instance that we would go for walks in the country and there would be somebody fishing in the beach or in the river and very often they would just haul the fish up and leave them in a basket flapping around while they suffocated and he would point that at me and say “I cant imagine how anybody could think it’s an enjoyable afternoon to sit on a riverbank while fish are slowly dying next to you,”

so that kind of I guess made me think about those things and then when I started to realise that this kind of suffering is also involved in meat production, you know we always ate meat, couldn’t really imagine family not having meat for dinner, then I started to think, yeah, this really does apply you know and it’s a much bigger issue than the stray angler, letting fish die slowly.

SO: Hmm, interesting. Okay the next question is if you had to name one animal study scholar who’s had a big impact on you, who would it be, and you’re going to be tempted to name me and I work but you must avoid that temptation.

PS: Its not easy because there has been a lot of good scholars but it’s not easy for me to say who has had the biggest influence but I think I would have to go back as I did to those beginnings, and talk probably about, so the first person who actually made
me think about this was Richard Keshin who’s a Canadian philosopher who hasn’t really written much about animals, but he did become a vegetarian but he was in turn influenced by Rosyn Godlovich who were also Canadians, all of this group was at Oxford when I was, and he did put me under them and Ross did write about animals as I say in an essay and co-edited that collection and so she was probably the
biggest influence on me.

SO: OK, so what’s the most important thing academics can do for animals?

PS: Academics have a big role in making sure that people are aware of this as an ethical issue so obviously most academics teach and it should be prominent in their courses and I particularly think it’s important to teach it alongside other issues so I for example have never taught a course only about animals but I teach courses in which there are issues like global poverty, maybe war, maybe the bioethical questions about life and death and a range of other issues and I always have animals there as one among a number of important moral issues, I think it’s important that people see this as something that if it’s something that you’re concerned about poverty and social justice and war and so on you should be concerned about animals as well.

SO: Interesting. SO if you had the power to change one thing about the human-non animal relationship what would that be?

PS: It would be the fact that we consume animals flesh and other products because I think that’s the cause of more animal suffering than anything else we do.
SO: OK, that’s a popular answer, so it’s a volume issue, so what are you working on next Peter?

PS: I’m revising another book called One World – a book about ethics and globalisation which came out in 2002 and which has been pretty well used in a lot of courses about global issues and international relations but all the facts have got very dated so

it needs an update so that’s what I’ve been up to.


SO: Oh, lovely. So where can people find out more about your work?

PS: There’s a website, you can google me and you can find a lot. So the website is a Princeton University website so https://uchv.princeton.edu/people/peter-singer, but if you google me you’ll find it and depending on what the nature of the work is you can google animal liberation and you can read about that, if you’re interested in my work on global poverty, there’s an organisation I’m involved with called The Life You Can Save, at thelifeyoucansave.org is the place to go.

SO: Wonderful. So thank you Peter and thank you to our listeners for joining us on Knowing Animals, the podcast where we talk to animal study scholars about their work. Don’t forget to follow us on Twitter at knowing_animals or Facebook at Knowing Animals. Also don’t forget to tell others about us and review the podcast on iTunes. Reviews make it easier for others to find us. I’m Siobhan O’Sullivan and I do like knowing animals. See ya! 

Tuesday, 10 July 2012

The UK's long history of animal protection and animal harm


Soon after arriving in Birmingham, England's second largest city, I headed out for lunch. The closest eating area was the local shopping centre called 'The Bull Ring'.



Arriving at the Bull Ring, and seeing the magnificent statue of an angry bull, I was immediately reminded of the UK's long history of animal harm and animal protection.

The world's first modern animal protection statute, 'Martin's Act' was an act of the UK Parliament. Martin's Act became law in 1822, following many attempts to create legal protection for urban animals, particularly beasts of burden and animals used in sports and entertainment. Two years later, in 1824, the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals was founded. It would later become the Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSCPA).

More radical aspects of the contemporary animal protection movement also have their origins in the UK, most notably the Oxford Group which meet in the 1960s and 70s. That group gave us terms such as 'speciesism' and was also where Peter Singer began thinking about the issues he would later articulate in his book Animals Liberation (1975). 

But while the UK has a proud history of animal protection, it also has a dark past.

The Bull Ring is most likely where bull baiting was conducted in Birmingham in the 17th and 18th centuries. 

Here is a definition of bull baiting by Mike Radford who wrote a history of animal welfare laws in the UK:

Bull-baiting involved tying a bull to a stake and setting one or more dogs upon it, the object being for the dogs to get hold of, and hang on to, the bull’s nose. Other animals used for baiting included bears and badgers. Bull-running was a variation on this, during which a bull was chased through the town until it became exhausted, whereupon dogs were set upon it (Radford 2001:18).

Here is a description of the practice, that appeared in the magazine 'Rural Sports', probably in the late 18th century:

The animal is fastened to a stake driven into the ground for the purpose, and about seven or eight yards of rope left loose, so as to allow him sufficient liberty for the fight. In this situation a bulldog is slipped at him, and endeavours to seize him by the nose; if the bull be well practised at the business, he will receive the dog on the horns, throw him off, and sometimes kill him; but, on the contrary, if the bull is not very dexterous, the dog will not only seize him by the nose, but will cling to his hold till the bull stands still; and this is termed pinning the bull. What are called good game bulls are very difficult to be pinned, being constantly on their guard, and placing their noses closer to the ground, they receive their antagonist on their horne; and it is astonishing to what distance they will sometimes throw him (cited in Fairholm and Pain 1924:75-76). 

I wonder how many people who shop at the modern day Bull Ring are aware of the shopping centre’s dark past. I also wonder how many spare a thought for all the bulls that must have suffered over many hundreds of years, right in the centre of Birmingham. 









Sunday, 8 July 2012

The Dutch Party for the Animals

One of the interesting things I learnt at Minding Animals had to do with the work of the Dutch Party for the Animals. 


The Party for the Animals was formed in response to a backlash against vegans and animal rights activists that occurred when an environmentalist/animal rights activists shot and killed a Dutch politician in 2002.


The Party for the Animals has since gone on to contest a number of Dutch elections and now holds two seats in the national Parliament. As they say on their website:


In the Netherlands, we are represented in the House of Representatives, the Senate, the Provincial States and in six city councils. That is unique: never before has a political party devoted to animal welfare been elected to a national parliament anywhere else in the world. 


The party has been working on many issues, including religious slaughter. As part of that work they uses Peter Singer's attendance at Minding Animals as an opportunity and asked Prof. Singer to address the Dutch Parliament. 


As well as making the address, Peter Singer also wrote an opinion piece on ritual slaughter and religious freedom. In it he argues that the solution is simple. If your religion requires that you harm animals in the production of meat, just do what he does - don't eat meat. Singer writes:



When people are prohibited from practicing their religion — for example, by laws that bar worshiping in certain ways — there can be no doubt that their freedom of religion has been violated. But prohibiting the ritual slaughter of animals does not stop Jews or Muslims from practicing their religion. During the debate on the Party for the Animals’ proposal, Rabbi Binyomin Jacobs, chief rabbi of the Netherlands, told members of parliament: “If we no longer have people who can do ritual slaughter in the Netherlands, we will stop eating meat.” And that, of course, is what one should do, if one adheres to a religion that requires animals to be slaughtered in a manner less humane than can be achieved by modern techniques.
Neither Islam nor Judaism upholds a requirement to eat meat. And I am not calling upon Jews and Muslims to do any more than I have chosen to do myself, for ethical reasons, for more than 40 years.


One of the interesting things about hearing members of the Party for the Animals speak at Minding Animals is that they feel as though their presence in Parliament has forced other parties to think about their position on animals - and to also defend it!


As a post script, on arriving in Amsterdam I bought a falafel at a vegetarian shop in town. I got talking to the person next to me and he told me that he is a member of the Party for the Animals and that 'it is the only political party he could belong to'. However, he was also critical of their stance on ritual slaughter. He argued that their approach had put others offside. I was very interested to hear his views and I look forward to learning more about the Dutch party for the animals as I travel around the country.  

Friday, 6 July 2012

Day Two of Minding Animals

The second day of Minding Animals began for me with a study circle discussion on 'Animals, Politics and the Law'. Legal and political scholars, as well as political actors, came together to discuss all things to do with animals and politics. A robust discussion followed, and I encouraged participants to think about ways political and legal human-animal studies scholars might remain connected outside of conferences. One suggestion I made was that we work through the newly established Centre for Animals and Social Justice (CSAJ) which is based at Sheffield University.  

In the afternoon I attended the Public Policy and Political Philosophy session where I heard Dan Lyons talk about ways of reforming animal research regulation to better allow the voices of nonhuman animals to be heard; and a paper by Brett Mizelle about the mass killing of pigs.

The highlight of the day was the afternoon keynote in which Robert Garner spoke about his latest work 'A Theory of Justice for Animals' and Will Kymlicka outlined his new approach to animal protection.

As a political scientist it is wonderful to see other political scientists take up, and address, the place of nonhuman animals in our political system.

Both men had strong messages to deliver and question time was somewhat heated - just what we like to see at an animals conference!

It was then time for a quick drink before the evening session which was a podium discussion featuring Peter Singer, Will Kymlicka and members the various European Union (EU) institutions that manage the life of nonhuman animals.

I asked what members of the panel think about the OIE. EU politicians answered my question. While they were polite, I got the feeling that the EU's relationship with the OIE might be a 'complex' one.

Overall the panel discussion was interesting. The theme was 'the future of animal politics'. But again I was very disappointed to see that of the 8 people on the stage, only one was a woman.

Monday, 11 June 2012

Peter Singer Appointed to the Order of Australia

I was thrilled to wake this morning to learn that Prof. Peter Singer has been appointed to the Order of Australia.


A well deserved honour in my opinion.


Peter Singer rose to prominence with the publication of his 1975 classic Animal Liberation. 




Often referred to as the bible of the animal rights movement, Animal Liberation has been through numerous re-prints and remains one of the first books I recommend to students who wish to learn about animal protection concepts. 


Peter Singer has achieved much since 1975. He has been a prolific author, theorists, commentator and philanthropist. His website www.thelifeyoucansave.com has raised $65million since its inception, all based on individuals pleading to donate a proportion of their income to those less well off. He also continues to support many animal charities, including Animals Australia who undertook the investigation into live animal exports publicised on 4 Corners last year. 


Over the past 40 odd years Peter Singer has faced considerable criticism, including from animal advocates in Australia and elsewhere. I find that conflict disappointing and somewhat disheartening. Although Peter Singer's views may not be shared universally among the animal protection community, my opinion is that he has done much to promote an enhanced moral status for nonhuman animals. My observation is that many animal advocates who criticise Peter Singers' work have not in fact read much of it. A comprehensive list of his work is available here. Much of which includes free links to the text. 




In February this year is was my great honour to have Peter Singer launch my book Animals, Equality and Democracy. Peter Singer is pictured here with Glenys Oogjes at my book launch held at the University of Melbourne. The photo was taken by the team at Fair Projects. 


While the Queen's Birthday Honour List is so often filled with former politicians and sports people, it is wonderful to see an ethicist, particularly one who has done so much for animals, named. 


Congratulations Peter Singer.

Monday, 26 March 2012

Your Challenge: explain why eating meat is acceptable

In a post last week I recounted by experience at the Intelligence Squared debate in which the team speaking in favour of eating meat struggled to develop a single coherent argument and where one member of the pro-meat eating team, also a pig farmer, was apparently almost in tears during question time.

It seems that I'm not the only person curious about how you might justify eating meat (in cases where other food is available). The New York Times would also like to know how meat eaters justify their actions. They are calling for 600 word entries. Submissions are due by April 8.

Entries will be judges by Peter Singer, Michael Pollan, Mark Bittman, Jonathan Safran Foer and Andrew Light. While Carol Adams has already responded to the judging panel by arguing that sexism is alive and well at the New York Times, it is nonetheless a tough panel and I am therefore hoping to see some very highly quality argument. 

I would love to enter, but try as I might, I just can't think of a sustainable, coherent arguments. How do you justify eating meat?

Academics from the world's top ranked university have recently published findings in a top-tier peer reviewed journal that suggest that 'red meat consumption is associated with an increased risk of total, cardiovascular, and cancer mortality'. Their results were generated by following 37,698 men and 83,644 women for up to 28 years. Over the past two weeks I have tried to find a published, peer reviewed study, from a respected institution, that demonstrates that there are health benefits associated with meat consumption. So far I have drawn a blank. (If any readers know of a suitable study I would love to hear about it).

So the health questions seems to be settled - eating meat is not a good idea if longevity or avoiding cancer is a priority for you.

Environmentally it is extremely difficult to make a pro-meat argument. Meat production appears to be inefficient, wasteful of water and it generates a massive amount of waste. And of course the suffering of animals in factory farms is well documented. 

So where will the winning entry turn? Pleasure? It is certainly clear that eating meat makes many people very happy. Tradition? It is something humans have done for a VERY long time and many social events and traditions are associated with eating animals. Those seem to be the two strongest arguments. But given all the negatives associated with eating meat the winning entrant will need to be very clearer and also demonstrate why human pleasure is more important that animal suffering. A very hard gig indeed. 

I can't wait to read the winning entry - get writing!!!

Thursday, 22 March 2012

The Difficult Job of Justifying Meat

While most people eat meat, and almost all meat comes from factory farms, it seems that justifying both factory farming AND meat eating generally, is becoming a difficult challenge - especially among well education urban types.


I was reminded of this on Tuesday night when I attended the Intelligence Squared debate 'should animals be off the menu?': http://wheelercentre.com/dailies/post/22b6c7dc3f5e/. Hosted by the Wheeler Centre: http://wheelercentre.com/ at the Melbourne Town Hall.


Speaking to a full house, which clearly included many animal advocates, the team lead by Peter Singer appeared to have the much easier task.


The photo was taken on my mobile phone. I was seated in the second level and apparently it was the largest turn out for a debate yet. 


Those who were tasked with defending meat eating struggled from the start. The first speaker for the negative, Fiona Chambers, was not able to provide a coherent account of why animals should be on the menu, and during question time was seemingly on the verge of tears. But while the arguments were challenging for the negative, Adrian Richardson proved a popular and charismatic speaker. 


I  have long admired Peter Singer and felt that his capacity of logical debate was second to none. Yet Phil Wollen was immensely popular with the audience.


In the end the debate was won by the affirmative - animals should be off the menu. Some people appeared to change their mind as a result of the debate. However, I can't help but notice that the debate result stand in stark contrast to the reality of meat consumption. Phil Wollen reminded the audience that in the time it took of the debate to be held, 13 million animals were killed for meat. Seems like a large number if most people agree that animals should be off the menu! 

Friday, 24 February 2012

The Book Launch is Done and Dusted - thank you for your support!

Glenys Oogjes (Animals Australia); Peter Singer and Siobhan O'Sullivan at the 'Animals, Equality and Democracy' book launch

Glenys addresses the crowd

Peter Singer does me the great honour of launching the book

I address the crowd

Siobhan O'Sullivan, Glenys Oogjes and Peter Singer

Animals, Equality and Democracy

Now that my book launch is over I have a moment to reflect on what it meant to me.

First, it was wonderful to see so many people take time out of their busy lives to celebrate with me. It was a real honour.

It was also humbling to have the book launched by two such eminent people: Prof. Peter Singer, author of Animal Liberation (1975) and Glenys Oogjes, long time CEO of Animals Australia. Both Peter and Glenys have been leading lights in the field for so long. As I said in my speech, I certainly knew them long before they knew me. It is therefore so meaningful to me to have developed a relationship with both and to have them support me by launching my book.

Third, it was a chance to catch my breath before commencing a new project. I would love to write more about the history of pit ponies. If you don't know what a pit pony is you will have to buy my book 'Animals, Equality and Democracy' http://www.amazon.com/Animals-Equality-Democracy-Palgrave-MacMillan/dp/0230243878 to find out!

Monday, 20 February 2012

Book Launch

It is now only two sleeps until I launch my book 'Animals, Equality and Democracy' http://www.oxfordanimalethics.com/2011/11/new-book-exposes-inconsistencies-in-animal-protection-laws/.

I am thrilled to have Peter Singer and Glenys Oogjes from Animals Australia helping me launch the book.

I see the launch as an opportunity to celebrate with friends and family and also take a deep breath before starting the next project.

The launch also brings to mind book reviews. I am aware that my book has been reviewed for the journal Society & Animals, but the review has not appeared in print yet. I am also yet to see a review on Amazon http://www.amazon.com/Animals-Equality-Democracy-Palgrave-MacMillan/dp/0230243878.

I have received many well wishes from people not able to attend the launch. To all those people who have taken the time to send me a note, thank you very much, and I hope you enjoy the book!


Friday, 17 February 2012

Animals Should be off the Menu

http://wheelercentre.com/calendar/event/animals-should-be-off-the-menu/

I'm really looking forward to his event: Intelligence Squared Debates: Animals Should be Off the Menu

I have heard Peter Singer speak many times. He is poised, smart and witty. He also knows how to pack a room. I recommend getting tickets early as I expect it to sell out. I have seen Peter Singer pack the Sydney Town Hall. Be quick!

Speaking of Peter Singer. He will be launching my book 'Animals, Equality and Democracy' on Wednesday February 22nd at the University of Melbourne. It's a wonderful honour to have Peter Singer launch the book. I'm really looking forward to the night. 

To learn more about my research and the book launch 'like' me on Facebook at: https://www.facebook.com/pages/Knowing-Animals-Past-and-Present/268973009788818.