Showing posts with label Carol Adams. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Carol Adams. Show all posts

Sunday, 17 June 2012

Sex Sells - but should it be used to sell an animal rights message?

Las Vegan Bakery on Smith Street, Melbourne hosts a regular animal rights discussion group. I have been invited as special guest speaker this Wednesday and the topic they have set me is: Sex Sells - but should it be used to sell an animal rights message?


So what do I think about the link between sex, sexism and animal rights?


Carol Adams famously began the conversation with the publication of The Sexual Politics of Meat in 1990.  


In Carol Adams' own words:

The 'Sexual Politics of Meat: A Feminist-Vegetarian Critical Theory' explores a relationship between patriarchal values and meat eating by interweaving the insights of feminism, vegetarianism, animal defense, and literary theory.


Yet despite warnings from Carol Adams and others about the link between the exploitation and subjugation of women and nonhuman animals, sex is regularly used to promote an animal rights message. 


People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) claims to be the world's biggest animal rights organisation. It is also the organisations most famous for using images of naked, or semi-naked people (usually women) to grab the media's attention and make (or be) the headlines. Their strategy has been spectacularly successful and the media does not seem to tire of a naked PETA protest.    










The abundance of online photos of naked PETA protests suggests that the organisation has no problem finding people willing to strip in the name of animal rights. Indeed, in scrolling through images for this post I saw numerous photos of people I have personally met, posing nude for PETA. I can only assume that those people do not think that the use of sex to sell an animal rights message is an ethical concern. Indeed, of the people I know who have stripped for PETA I am not aware of any of them feeling pressured, coerced or exploited in the process. 


But has PETA taken it to another level?


Regular readers of this blog will recall that earlier this year PETA produced an online ad which suggested that a young woman had sustained serious injuries after her boyfriend went vegan and therefore became more forceful in bed. As you might expect, the ad caused quite a stir.


More recently PETA launched a new xxx website which features a photos of two young, apparently naked, women embracing. At first blush it appears to be a porn site. 


The site includes a statement under the heading 'The Reason Behind PETA's Naked Campaigns' which reads in part:


PETA's mission is to put an end to animal suffering, and we use every available opportunity to spread this message—we always have, and we always will. Unfortunately, this is not always an easy task. Unlike our opposition, which is mostly made up of wealthy industries and corporations, PETA must rely on getting free "advertising" through media coverage. It's a safe bet that many visitors to PETA.xxx didn't set out to learn about how animals are mercilessly slaughtered on today's factory farms; understandably, such topics are convenient to ignore. That's why PETA must make our message impossible to forget—and launching a website with a .xxx domain name is one way that we can achieve that goal.


In PETA's view sex is fair game because the suffering of animals is so serious, and their adversaries so powerful, that they must harness the free advertising that comes with sexual images.They do so for the sake of the animals. 


So what's my view?


Well, I can see both sides of the argument. I appreciate that the sexualisation of women's bodies for the purpose of marketing is morally problematic. I also continue to be impressed with the effectiveness with which PETA disseminates its message. In a world where animal suffering is almost always invisible, their contribution is arguably important. 


But do the ends justify the means? Well to learn what I really, really, really think about the issue you will have to come to the Las Vegan Bakery discussion group.


However, what I will tell you now is that I will be watching the number of hits this post receives very closely. I have tagged it with the word 'sex'. What's the bet that this post will receive more page views than any other? Sex sells, but should animal advocates fight them or join them?  





Monday, 26 March 2012

Your Challenge: explain why eating meat is acceptable

In a post last week I recounted by experience at the Intelligence Squared debate in which the team speaking in favour of eating meat struggled to develop a single coherent argument and where one member of the pro-meat eating team, also a pig farmer, was apparently almost in tears during question time.

It seems that I'm not the only person curious about how you might justify eating meat (in cases where other food is available). The New York Times would also like to know how meat eaters justify their actions. They are calling for 600 word entries. Submissions are due by April 8.

Entries will be judges by Peter Singer, Michael Pollan, Mark Bittman, Jonathan Safran Foer and Andrew Light. While Carol Adams has already responded to the judging panel by arguing that sexism is alive and well at the New York Times, it is nonetheless a tough panel and I am therefore hoping to see some very highly quality argument. 

I would love to enter, but try as I might, I just can't think of a sustainable, coherent arguments. How do you justify eating meat?

Academics from the world's top ranked university have recently published findings in a top-tier peer reviewed journal that suggest that 'red meat consumption is associated with an increased risk of total, cardiovascular, and cancer mortality'. Their results were generated by following 37,698 men and 83,644 women for up to 28 years. Over the past two weeks I have tried to find a published, peer reviewed study, from a respected institution, that demonstrates that there are health benefits associated with meat consumption. So far I have drawn a blank. (If any readers know of a suitable study I would love to hear about it).

So the health questions seems to be settled - eating meat is not a good idea if longevity or avoiding cancer is a priority for you.

Environmentally it is extremely difficult to make a pro-meat argument. Meat production appears to be inefficient, wasteful of water and it generates a massive amount of waste. And of course the suffering of animals in factory farms is well documented. 

So where will the winning entry turn? Pleasure? It is certainly clear that eating meat makes many people very happy. Tradition? It is something humans have done for a VERY long time and many social events and traditions are associated with eating animals. Those seem to be the two strongest arguments. But given all the negatives associated with eating meat the winning entrant will need to be very clearer and also demonstrate why human pleasure is more important that animal suffering. A very hard gig indeed. 

I can't wait to read the winning entry - get writing!!!